Olive Garden Alfredo Casserole – Restaurant Copycat

I’ve nailed a copycat recipe for Olive Garden’s Alfredo Casserole, inspired by its Italian roots with rich butter, Parmesan, and creamy sauce over al dente pasta. It’s simple: boil the noodles, sauté garlic in butter, mix in cream and veggies, then bake until bubbly. Don’t forget tips like swapping proteins or adding mushrooms for a twist. You’ll uncover all the tools and secrets ahead.

History

SAVE IT

Olive Garden’s Alfredo Casserole draws its roots from traditional Italian cuisine, particularly the creamy Alfredo sauce invented in early 20th-century Rome by Alfredo di Lelio, which blends butter and Parmesan for a rich, indulgent flavor.

This dish reflects Italian-American cultural adaptations, where classic recipes are often enhanced with additional ingredients like pasta, vegetables, or proteins to suit broader American tastes.

Regional variations in the U.S. might include heartier versions in the Midwest with added meats or lighter coastal twists with seafood, signifying the evolution of immigrant traditions; these adaptations highlight how Italian food has become a symbol of comfort and fusion.

Traditionally, it’s served during family gatherings, casual dinners, or festive occasions like holidays, emphasizing its role as a hearty, shareable meal in everyday and celebratory contexts.

Ingredients

SAVE IT

– Butter: Ah, let’s kick things off with that rich, velvety Butter—think of it as the unsung hero that turns a simple sauce into something downright dreamy, you know, without which no Alfredo would dare show its face.

It’s that essential base that whispers promises of comfort on a chilly evening.

– Parmesan cheese: Now, here’s the star of the show, freshly grated Parmesan, all nutty and sharp, making you wonder how something so simple could pack such a flavorful punch.

It’s like that friend who’s always got your back, adding that irresistible cheesy depth that keeps you coming back for more, even if it means sneaking an extra sprinkle.

– Pasta: We’re talking about sturdy Pasta noodles, like fettuccine or penne, which soak up all that creamy goodness like a sponge in a spill—oh, the choices, right, should it be the twirly kind or the straight ones.

Either way, it’s the canvas for this casserole, holding everything together in a hearty, satisfying tangle.

– Heavy cream: Don’t overlook this creamy teammate, Heavy cream that smooths out the sauce to perfection, giving it that luxurious flow.

It’s the one ingredient that might make you pause and think, is this worth the calories, but hey, life’s too short for regrets when it comes to a dish this cozy.

– Garlic: A few cloves of fresh Garlic, minced just right, adding that zesty kick without overwhelming the scene.

It’s like a playful sidekick, sneaking in to liven things up and make your kitchen smell like a cozy Italian getaway, even on a random Tuesday.

– Vegetables, like broccoli or spinach: Toss in some vibrant veggies, say a cup of chopped broccoli or a handful of spinach, because who says a casserole can’t sneak in a bit of green.

They’re the healthy twist that balances the richness, almost like they’re whispering, “Hey, we’re here to make you feel good about your choices.”

– Protein, such as chicken or shrimp: For that extra heartiness, grab about a pound of cooked chicken or shrimp—it’s the optional boost that turns a simple side into a main event, making you ponder, do I go for the classic or mix it up.

Either way, it’s like adding a fun plot twist to the story.

– Salt and pepper: Basic but brilliant, a pinch of salt and a dash of pepper to taste—because even the simplest things can elevate the whole mix, you might find yourself second-guessing, is that enough zing.

It’s the everyday magic that pulls everything together without stealing the spotlight.

– Breadcrumbs or additional cheese for topping: Finally, a light sprinkle of breadcrumbs or more Parmesan on top, creating that golden, crispy layer.

It’s the finishing touch that makes you smile, thinking, why not add a little crunch to keep things interesting in this otherwise smooth affair.

Cooking Steps

SAVE IT

Let’s jump into making this Olive Garden Alfredo Casserole, where you’ll turn simple ingredients into a cozy, creamy masterpiece that feels like a hug in a dish.

First off, start by boiling about 8 ounces of sturdy pasta noodles, like fettuccine or penne, in a large pot of salted water until they’re al dente—think that perfect tender bite that holds up without turning mushy.

While the pasta cooks, you can sauté a few cloves of fresh garlic in, say, 2 tablespoons of butter over medium heat in a big skillet, letting that aroma fill your kitchen and make you wonder if you’re secretly a pro chef.

Once your garlic is fragrant and softened, about 1-2 minutes, pour in 1 cup of heavy cream to create that silky base, stirring gently as it heats up and thickens into a sauce that’ll have you pausing to appreciate the magic of simple ingredients.

Add in your vegetables—like a cup of chopped broccoli or a handful of spinach—and cook them until they’re just tender, maybe 3-4 minutes, to keep that fresh crunch without overwhelming the creaminess.

Now, for the assembly, here’s how to pull it all together in a numbered list that keeps things straightforward:

1. Combine the sauce and add-ins: Mix the cooked pasta, about a pound of your chosen protein like cooked chicken or shrimp, into the creamy sauce in the skillet, then stir in freshly grated Parmesan cheese—around 1 cup should do it—to melt and create that nutty, cheesy depth we all crave.
2. Season and layer: Sprinkle in a pinch of salt and a dash of pepper to taste, adjusting as you go because, let’s face it, everyone’s got their own idea of the perfect zing, and you might find yourself sneaking in an extra pinch just for fun.
3. Bake it up: Transfer everything to a greased baking dish, spread it out evenly, and pop it in a preheated oven at 350°F for about 20-25 minutes, until it’s bubbly and golden on top, giving you that satisfying casserole vibe without any fuss.

There you have it, a step-by-step guide that turns everyday ingredients into something special, leaving you with a dish that’s as rewarding to make as it’s to eat—almost like you’ve got a little Italian secret up your sleeve.

Tips and Variations

SAVE IT

If you’re tweaking this Olive Garden Alfredo Casserole, consider swapping in whole wheat pasta for a nuttier bite that might make you feel a tad virtuous, or amp up the veggies with colorful bell peppers and mushrooms to sneak in extra nutrients without anyone noticing the sneaky greens.

You might wonder, what if I ditch the chicken for flaky salmon or even go meat-free with hearty chickpeas for a lighter twist that still packs that creamy punch?

And here’s a fun tip: to avoid a sauce that’s too thick—like something out of a comedy sketch where everything sticks—stir in a splash of pasta water before baking, because who knew a little liquid gold could save the day, turning your dish into a crowd-pleaser that’s easy to customize.

Tools