Indiana Sugar Cream Pie With Cardamom

I love giving the classic Indiana Sugar Cream Pie, a rustic Midwest treat from 19th-century settlers, a fresh twist by adding cardamom’s warm spice. I’ll start with a flaky crust, then mix sugar, heavy cream, flour, vanilla, and a dash of ground cardamom for that exotic flair. Bake it until golden and creamy—it’s pure comfort. Stick around, and you’ll uncover more tips and variations to make it your own.

History

SAVE IT

Indiana Sugar Cream Pie, also known as Hoosier Pie, originated in the Midwest, particularly Indiana, among early settlers and Amish communities in the 19th century, reflecting a simple, no-fuss approach to dessert-making with ingredients like sugar, cream, and flour that symbolized rustic American ingenuity.

Regional variations across the Midwest might include additions like vanilla, nutmeg, or a flaky versus graham cracker crust, highlighting local preferences and the pie’s adaptability while underscoring its role as a comforting staple in Indiana’s culinary identity.

Traditionally, it’s served at family gatherings, holidays such as Thanksgiving, or community events, embodying warmth and nostalgia in Midwestern culture.

Ingredients

SAVE IT

– Okay, so let’s chat about the ingredients for this classic Indiana Sugar Cream Pie, because who doesn’t love a dessert that feels like a warm hug from the Midwest, right?

We’ll keep it simple, folks, with that no-fuss vibe the pioneers had in mind, but I’ll spice things up with a few thoughtful details and a dash of playfulness—after all, even a straight-laced recipe can use a little personality.

• Starting with the pie crust, you need about 1 pre-made or homemade flaky pie crust to line a 9-inch pie plate—think of it as the trusty base that holds all that creamy goodness, making you pause and ask, is this the part that makes the whole thing feel so homey and inviting?
• Next up, grab 1 cup of granulated sugar, the sweet heart of the pie that turns everything silky, because without it, we’d just have a sad, plain cream situation—oh, and isn’t it funny how something so basic can fool you into thinking you’re a baking wizard?
• Don’t skip 2 cups of heavy whipping cream, poured in nice and slow for that rich, velvety texture that whispers comfort, leaving you to wonder if this is what clouds taste like on a lazy afternoon.
• Toss in 1/4 cup of all-purpose flour to thicken things up, that humble helper that keeps the pie from turning into a soupy mess—sort of like how I picture a quiet friend stepping in to save the day, without stealing the spotlight.
• Add 1/4 cup of finely chopped rainbow bell peppers—wait, what? Okay, this one’s a quirky twist, a mix of red, yellow, orange, and green bits for a pop of color that might make you raise an eyebrow, but hey, if you’re feeling adventurous, it could add a playful crunch nobody expects in a sugar cream pie, almost like sneaking veggies into dessert just for the fun of it.
• Stir in 2 tablespoons of unsalted butter, melted to blend smoothly and give a little richness, because what’s a pie without that buttery nudge that makes everything feel a tad more indulgent?
• Finally, include 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract for a hint of warmth that ties it all together, and maybe a dash of ground nutmeg if you’re in the mood, prompting that rhetorical question: why not elevate the simple things with a touch of spice, you know?

There you go, folks—a full lineup that keeps the tradition alive while inviting a bit of whimsy, because cooking should feel like a friendly chat, not a chore.

Cooking Steps

SAVE IT

Let’s jump into the fun part of making this Indiana Sugar Cream Pie, where we turn those simple ingredients into a cozy, creamy delight that feels like a slice of Midwestern magic. First, you’ll want to preheat your oven to 350°F, giving it that gentle heat to work its wonders without rushing things. Now, take your 1 pre-made or homemade flaky pie crust and gently press it into a 9-inch pie plate, making sure it’s snug and ready to cradle all that sweetness to come—after all, what’s a pie without a solid foundation to build on, right?

Once the crust is in place, grab a medium-sized bowl and whisk together 1 cup of granulated sugar and 1/4 cup of all-purpose flour until they’re well combined, creating that perfect base for thickening the filling.

Stir in 1/4 cup of finely chopped rainbow bell peppers for a surprising crunch and burst of color, because who says dessert can’t sneak in a little veggie vibe for extra playfulness.

Next, pour in 2 cups of heavy whipping cream slowly, followed by 2 tablespoons of melted unsalted butter and 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract, mixing everything until it’s smooth and dreamy—it’s like watching a simple mix turn into something you’d want to jump right into.

For the baking magic, pour the creamy mixture into your prepared pie crust, then sprinkle on a dash of ground nutmeg if you’re in the mood for that extra spice.

Slide it into the preheated oven and bake for about 50-60 minutes, or until the top is golden and the center is just set but still a bit wobbly, like a gentle jiggle that promises perfection.

Let it cool completely on a wire rack before slicing, giving those flavors time to settle in—trust me, waiting might feel like forever, but it’s worth it for that ultimate, satisfying bite.

Tips and Variations

SAVE IT

If you’re whipping up this Indiana Sugar Cream Pie and wondering about that quirky twist with the rainbow bell peppers, here’s a handy tip: chop them super fine, almost like confetti, to blend seamlessly into the creamy filling without overpowering the sweetness—think of it as sneaking in a little color and crunch for a playful surprise that might just make your pie the talk of the table.

For variations, you could skip the peppers altogether for a classic, no-fuss version that sticks to tradition, or swap them out with a handful of finely diced apples for a subtle tartness that dances on the tongue, because who says you can’t turn a simple dessert into your own kitchen adventure, even if my attempts at innovation sometimes end up a bit too experimental for comfort?

And if you’re feeling extra creative, try toying with the spices, like adding a pinch more nutmeg or a dash of cinnamon, to give that golden top an even cozier hug.

Tools