Creamy Macaroni Salad | Ohio | Elbow Macaroni, Mayo, Sweet Relish

I love whipping up a creamy macaroni salad Ohio-style, using elbow macaroni as the base, mayo for that rich creaminess, and sweet relish for a tangy twist that screams Midwestern comfort. First, I boil the macaroni until tender, drain it, then mix in the mayo and relish with crunchy add-ins like diced celery and onion. It’s simple and satisfying for any gathering. If you hang on, I’ll share more on its history and handy tips.

History

SAVE IT

Creamy Macaroni Salad originated in the United States during the late 19th century, drawing from European pasta traditions and evolving into a staple of American comfort food, reflecting diverse cultural influences like Italian-American heritage.

Regional variations, such as the sweeter, creamier Hawaiian style, showcase local ingredients and signify the dish’s adaptability to different tastes and communities, enhancing its role in multicultural cuisine.

Traditionally, it’s served at summer barbecues, picnics, holidays like the Fourth of July, and family potlucks, where its invigorating and versatile nature makes it a go-to side dish for casual gatherings.

Ingredients

SAVE IT

• Elbow macaroni: Oh, let’s start with the star of the show here, those curvy little pasta pieces that soak up all the flavors like a sponge at a summer picnic—have you ever noticed how they just beg to be mixed into something creamy and cool?
• Mayonnaise: This creamy base is what turns a simple salad into something downright irresistible, the kind that makes you pause and think, “How does something so straightforward make everything else sing?”

Go for a good-quality one, maybe about 1 cup, to get that smooth, velvety texture without overwhelming the mix.

• Celery stalks: Crunchy and fresh, these add a nice snap to balance the softness, like a reliable sidekick in the kitchen—picture them diced into bite-sized pieces, say 2 or 3 stalks, because who doesn’t love a bit of texture that keeps things interesting?
• Red onion: A colorful twist that brings a mild bite and a pop of purple, making you wonder if it’s the unsung hero of the bunch—chop up about half a medium one for that subtle zing, but if you’re feeling playful, soak it in water first to tame its edge, you know, for those who prefer things a tad milder.
• Bell peppers: Whether red, green, or yellow, these bright veggies sneak in sweetness and crunch, almost like they’re winking at you from the bowl—aim for one diced pepper to add variety without stealing the spotlight, because variety is the spice of life, or at least of salads.
• Hard-boiled eggs: Chopped up for a protein punch, these make the salad feel more substantial, like they’re saying, “Hey, we’re here to fill you up”—you’ll need about 2 or 3, peeled and diced, to give that creamy mix a hearty nod.
• Dijon mustard: Just a tablespoon or so of this tangy wonder to wake up the flavors, making you ask, “How does a little kick turn ordinary into extraordinary?” It’s that secret nudge that adds depth, without going overboard.
• White vinegar: A splash, say 1 to 2 tablespoons, for a bright acidity that cuts through the richness—think of it as the clever balancer, keeping things from getting too heavy, because sometimes less is more in the flavor game.
• Salt and black pepper: Basics that every cook reaches for, like old friends in the spice rack—start with a teaspoon of salt and a half-teaspoon of pepper, adjusting to taste, because who doesn’t enjoy tweaking things to make it just right?
• Optional add-ins, like sweet pickles or tuna: If you’re in the mood for extras, toss in a handful of chopped pickles for a sweet crunch or a can of drained tuna for heartiness—it’s all about making it your own, with a playful twist that says, “Why not add a little surprise?”

Cooking Steps

SAVE IT

Alright, let’s get down to the fun part of whipping up this creamy macaroni salad—it’s all about turning those simple ingredients into a crowd-pleasing dish that hits the spot on a warm day.

Start by cooking the elbow macaroni, which is the heart of the salad, making sure to use enough to fill your bowl—say, about 8 ounces or so, based on what feels right for your crowd.

Boil it in a large pot of salted water until it’s just tender, usually around 7 to 9 minutes, then drain and rinse under cold water to stop the cooking process and keep it from turning into a sticky nightmare.

Once your macaroni is cooled and ready, it’s time to mix in the other stars of the show.

Grab about 1 cup of mayonnaise for that smooth, creamy base, and stir it into a big bowl with the cooked macaroni, along with 2 or 3 diced celery stalks for some crunch and half a medium red onion, chopped fine for a mild bite that won’t overwhelm the flavors.

Add in one diced bell pepper for a sweet pop, 2 or 3 chopped hard-boiled eggs for a protein boost, a tablespoon of Dijon mustard for tang, and 1 to 2 tablespoons of white vinegar to brighten things up—don’t forget a teaspoon of salt and half a teaspoon of black pepper to tie it all together.

Now, give everything a good toss until it’s evenly coated, and if you’re feeling adventurous, throw in optional add-ins like sweet pickles or tuna for an extra twist.

Let the salad chill in the fridge for at least an hour, or longer if you can wait, because that resting time lets the flavors mingle and dance, turning a simple mix into something truly magical.

Who knew a little patience could make such a difference, right?

Tips and Variations

SAVE IT

When it comes to jazzing up your creamy macaroni salad, let’s keep things simple yet clever—start by tweaking the basics for a personalized twist, like swapping half the mayonnaise for tangy Greek yogurt to lighten it up without losing that luscious creaminess, or adding a handful of fresh herbs like dill for a herby kick that makes every bite feel like a garden party.

Now, if you’re feeling experimental, why not play with variations such as tossing in chopped sweet pickles for extra crunch or going veggie-forward with shredded carrots and zucchini, turning this classic into a colorful medley that surprises the taste buds; and oh, about those skewers in the back of your mind, while they’re not exactly for salad, you could humorously pretend to “skew” your add-ins for fun, like threading veggies before dicing them in, because who says preparation can’t have a little adventure?

Tools